Truck owner keeps paying EMIs, but bank seizes vehicle over default on another loan; consumer commission holds bank and parking yard liable, orders Rs 5 lakh compensation


Truck owner keeps paying EMIs, but bank seizes vehicle over default on another loan; consumer commission holds bank and parking yard liable, orders Rs 5 lakh compensation
AI generated image used for representative purpose

NEW DELHI: A consumer commission in Punjab has held a small finance bank and a vehicle recovery yard operator guilty of unfair trade practice for seizing a man’s truck despite him regularly paying its loan instalments. The commission directed them to jointly pay Rs 5 lakh as compensation and warned that failure to pay on time would attract a penalty of Rs 500 per day.In its November 3, 2026, order, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Ludhiana, held the bank and the yard operator responsible for taking away the truck over unpaid dues linked to another vehicle financed by the bank.

Bank seizes truck despite regular loan EMI payments

According to the commission order, the customer took a Rs 5.5 lakh loan from Equitas Small Finance Bank in January 2018 to buy a second-hand Tata 2518 truck, repayable in 63 monthly instalments. He said he regularly paid the EMIs until August 2021.On September 14, 2021, while carrying goods from Ludhiana to Siliguri, he was stopped near Karnal by a recovery agent acting on the bank’s instructions. Despite showing payment receipts, his truck was seized and taken to a yard run by Ravinder Lather. He alleged that the agent snatched his phone, slapped him and beat him. He also claimed that Rs 50,000 worth of diesel was left in the truck and that he lost around Rs 4 lakh in earnings as it was his only source of livelihood.However, the bank said the customer had defaulted on another Rs 10 lakh truck loan taken in July 2019. It claimed that although he voluntarily surrendered that vehicle in March 2021, its sale proceeds were insufficient to clear the dues. Since both loans were linked to the same borrower account, the bank argued that it could seize the first truck too. The yard operator denied forcibly taking the vehicle, saying he only provided parking space for vehicles brought by recovery agents.

Why commission held bank guilty of illegal truck repossession

The bench comprising president Sanjeev Batra and member Monika Bhagat found that the bank had illegally seized the truck despite regular EMI payments for that vehicle. It said the loan agreement allowed repossession only of the vehicle financed under that particular agreement and the bank had failed to prove that both loan accounts were classified as non-performing assets.“Penal action including ‘Repossession’, post possession sale and termination of contract can be initiated against the ‘Asset’ described in the schedule only. In the present case, the vehicle No.PB10-CZ-6397 was hypothecated asset with the bank for which the EMIs were regularly paid. There was no violation of the ‘Events of Default’ as enumerated in the loan agreements itself,” the commission said.On the yard operator’s role, the commission said he could not escape responsibility by claiming that he only provided parking space. It noted that he had failed to produce any agreement with the bank authorising him to provide such services.The bench also referred to the Supreme Court‘s criticism of banks hiring musclemen to recover vehicles, observing that banks must follow legally recognised procedures instead of using force.The commission said the customer had suffered financial loss and mental hardship after being deprived of the truck, which was his source of livelihood. It held both parties guilty of deficiency in service and unfair trade practice.

Final order

The commission partly allowed the complaint and directed the bank and yard operator, jointly and severally, to:

  • Pay Rs 5 lakh as compensation for the financial loss, mental agony and harassment caused to the customer.
  • Make the payment within 30 days of receiving a copy of the order.
  • If they fail to pay within the deadline, they will have to pay an additional Rs 500 per day from the date of the order until payment, subject to a maximum of Rs 2 lakh.
  • The commission did not award any separate amount towards litigation expenses.



Source link

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *