NEW DELHI: A consumer commission in Andhra Pradesh has directed an online seller and Amazon to refund Rs 27,000 to a woman who said she received a black polythene roll instead of the Seiko wristwatch she ordered. The commission also ordered Rs 21,000 as compensation and Rs 10,000 for litigation expenses, holding them liable for failing to produce documentary evidence on how her complaint and refund request were handled.
What was the Seiko watch dispute?
According to the commission order, the complainant, Kausari Khanum, had ordered a Seiko analogue men’s wristwatch with a green dial and silver-coloured strap (model SRPD61K1) for her son through Amazon on May 5, 2025. The watch was priced at Rs 30,000, but she paid Rs 27,000 after a 10 percent discount. She also paid Rs 399 for Amazon Prime membership.The expected delivery date was May 12. However, on May 11, the delivery agent brought package. After opening, Khanum found a black polythene roll in the box instead of the watch she ordered.She complained to Amazon’s customer care and requested a return. The package was picked up on May 13, but the refund was not issued. She later purchased the same watch from a Titan showroom in Visakhapatnam on June 23, 2025.In its defence, Samay Watches, the seller, claimed that it had packed the genuine watch and handed it over intact to Amazon’s logistics partner. It added that the substitution happened within Amazon’s delivery network and said it had itself raised a complaint with Amazon after receiving the returned package without the watch.Amazon maintained that its internal investigation found the correct product had been delivered, but a different item was returned, making the customer ineligible for a refund.
What did the commission said
The bench of president Dr Gudla Tanuja, member Varri Krishna Murthy and woman member Rahimunnisa Begum found that the seller and Amazon had failed to establish that the correct watch was delivered or that the refund issue was properly resolved.The commission noted that both parties blamed each other for the missing watch but failed to produce documents showing how the refund complaint was handled. It also noted that the seller’s documents showed receipt of the payment and failure to refund it.“The Commission is of the considered opinion that except blame game on each other the 1st and 3rd opposite Parties failed to adduce documentary evidence to the extent of the refund process of the watch in question being the prime concern of the complainant. The complainant has to suffer for no fault. The online sales mechanism i.e., the e-commerce entities instead of being supportive has turned into troublesome in the case in hand, hence the opposite parties are held liable,” the commission observed.The commission clarified that its decision was limited to the watch order. It said Khanum had not produced proof of payment for the second item, which was ordered separately on a cash-on-delivery basis. It gave her liberty to file a separate complaint over that transaction.Holding the seller and Amazon jointly liable for the watch refund, the bench said:“The Commission is of the considered opinion that the opposite parties failed to produce documentary evidence as regards to the problem solving methodology adopted, endorsed to the complainant as regards to the accurate delivery of the watch in dispute. Hence, the opposite parties are jointly and collectively held liable to refund the consideration amount received towards the watch in dispute to the complainant along with reasonable compensation for being subjected to mental agony and costs towards the unwarranted litigation.”The commission then directed the seller and Amazon to refund the Rs 27,000 paid for the watch, along with compensation and litigation expenses.
Final order
Announced on October 31, 2026, the District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission-I, Visakhapatnam, partly allowed the complaint and directed the seller and Amazon to:
- Refund Rs 27,000 with 6 percent annual interest from May 5, 2025, until realisation.
- Pay Rs 21,000 as compensation.
- Pay Rs 10,000 towards litigation expenses.
The opposite parties must comply within one month of receiving the order. In case of default, the interest on Rs 27,000 will increase from 6 percent to 9 percent annually for the period of default.