The Pratidhwani

US judge strikes down Trump rule restricting stays for foreign students, journalists


US judge strikes down Trump rule restricting stays for foreign students, journalists
US judge overturns Trump policy limiting stay of international students, journalists

A US federal judge on Monday struck down a Trump administration rule that sought to impose fixed periods of stay on foreign students, exchange visitors and international journalists, ruling that the policy was arbitrary and not in accordance with the law.District Judge F Dennis Saylor vacated the Department of Homeland Security’s (DHS) final rule under the Administrative Procedure Act (APA), granting a summary judgment in favour of the plaintiffs and rejecting the US government’s request to uphold the policy.The court held that the administration had failed to adequately justify the restrictions, assess their potential costs and benefits, or demonstrate that they were necessary to prevent immigration fraud and protect national security.“For the foregoing reasons, and the reasons set forth in the Memorandum and Order on Motion for Preliminary Injunction dated September 14, 2026, plaintiffs’ motion for summary judgment is GRANTED and defendants’ motion for summary judgment is DENIED,” the order signed by District Judge F Dennis Saylor read.“The Final Rule, entitled Establishing a Fixed Time Period of Admission and an Extension of Stay Procedure for Nonimmigrant Academic Students, Exchange Visitors, and Representatives of Foreign Information Media, 91 Fed. Reg. 44976 (July 17, 2026), is hereby VACATED pursuant to the Administrative Procedure Act, 5 USC. § 706,” it added.

Which visa categories were covered by the rule?

Published in the Federal Register on July 17, 2026, the rule sought to establish fixed periods of admission and a new extension-of-stay procedure for several categories of non-immigrants.It covered international students holding F-1 visas, researchers, professors and instructors under J-1 visas, and foreign journalists and media representatives holding I visas.The policy would have replaced the existing duration-of-status framework with fixed periods of stay, requiring affected foreign nationals to seek extensions under a new system.The court had previously issued a preliminary injunction on September 14, 2026, postponing the implementation of the rule under Section 705 of the APA. The US government subsequently appealed that decision before the US Court of Appeals for the First Circuit. The appeal was still pending when the latest order was issued.

Why did the court strike down the rule?

The court found that DHS had failed to adequately evaluate the potential consequences of the policy or provide sufficient evidence to support its claims that the restrictions were necessary to tackle fraud and national security concerns.It also questioned whether the department had properly considered less restrictive alternatives and addressed concerns raised during the public consultation process.A key issue was the existing Student and Exchange Visitor Information System (SEVIS), which allows authorities to monitor international students and exchange visitors through reporting and data collection by educational institutions.The plaintiffs argued that DHS should have considered making greater use of SEVIS before introducing a new system. They pointed to the responsibilities of Designated School Officials (DSOs) and Responsible Officers (ROs), who report information about foreign students and exchange visitors.The court noted that DHS had previously strengthened SEVIS, including implementing recommendations made by the Government Accountability Office in 2019. These measures included identifying fraud involving institutions seeking certification, verifying the eligibility of DSOs and developing a risk-assessment model.The department had also used SEVIS records to identify suspected abuses, investigate ‘pay-to-stay’ fraud and refer potential violations to field offices for further examination. It had additionally checked the records of more than one million students against the National Crime Information Centre to identify individuals whose behaviour could indicate fraudulent visa overstays.DHS, however, maintained that SEVIS was a ‘data-reporting system for schools, not an immigration-status adjudication system’.The court rejected the department’s justification, observing that it had not adequately explained how introducing a discretionary renewal system after a foreign student had already spent four years in the US would improve its ability to identify fraud.It also said DHS had failed to establish how the benefits of the proposed system would outweigh the costs of abandoning the existing framework.

Court flags restrictions on academic mobility

The judge also examined whether the proposed restrictions were consistent with the Immigration and Nationality Act, particularly Section 1101(a)(15)(F), which governs the F-1 student visa category.The provision allows a ‘bona fide student’ who qualifies to pursue a full course of study to enter the US temporarily for that purpose.DHS had argued that the department’s secretary had the authority to determine what constituted an appropriate course of study and could consequently impose restrictions on certain academic programmes.However, the court observed that the department’s interpretation could prevent foreign students from pursuing extended academic programmes, including PhD courses, joint degrees, changes in academic specialisation and programmes that were not at a higher academic level than their previous qualifications.Referring to the 2022 ruling in Washington Alliance of Technology Workers v. United States Department of Homeland Security, the court said Congress had reserved the authority to establish the terms of entry while delegating to the executive branch the power to determine the duration and conditions of non-immigrants’ stay in a manner reasonably connected to the purpose of their visa category.The judge concluded that DHS’s stated objectives of preventing fraud and protecting national security were not reasonably connected to the purpose of the F-1 visa programme.“Put bluntly, DHS is seeking to prevent or discourage the very activity—providing educational opportunities for foreign students in the United States—that Congress sought to permit and encourage,” the court observed.“The statute simply does not grant DHS such broad and open-ended authority to undermine the F-1 visa program,” it added.

Who challenged the Trump administration’s rule?

The legal challenge was brought by a coalition of higher education, labour and media organisations.The plaintiffs included the Presidents’ Alliance on Higher Education and Immigration, NAFSA: Association of International Educators, the Association of Independent Colleges and Universities in Massachusetts, the American Federation of Teachers, Graduate Labour Organisation (AFT Local 6516), The NewsGuild-CWA, International Union, United Automobile, Aerospace and Agricultural Implement Workers of America, and United Auto Workers Local 2322.The organisations challenged the administration’s proposed changes, arguing that the existing monitoring framework provided mechanisms to address concerns over immigration fraud and national security without imposing additional restrictions on foreign students, researchers and journalists.



Source link

Exit mobile version