The Pratidhwani

Gurgaon man pays Rs 14.8L stamp duty to acquire relative’s half share in property, says he was charged again on portion he already owned, consumer commission orders officials to refund Rs 7.38L with 9% interest and pay Rs 72,000 | Gurgaon News


Gurgaon man pays Rs 14.8L stamp duty to acquire relative's half share in property, says he was charged again on portion he already owned, consumer commission orders officials to refund Rs 7.38L with 9% interest and pay Rs 72,000
(AI image) Gulshan Kumar Bhutani challenged the district revenue administration for demanding excessive stamp duty on a property transfer.

GURGAON: A Gurgaon property buyer who was allegedly made to pay stamp duty twice on a share of a property he already co-owned has won a legal battle against the district revenue administration, with the consumer commission ordering the district revenue officer (DRO) and deputy commissioner (DC) to refund Rs 7.38 lakh collected in excess, along with 9% annual interest.The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission of Gurgaon has also directed the two officials to pay Rs 50,000 as compensation for mental harassment and Rs 22,000 towards litigation expenses. It warned that failure to comply with the order could invite execution proceedings and prosecution under the Consumer Protection Act.The complaint was filed by Gulshan Kumar Bhutani, who had jointly purchased a 250-square-yard residential property in Sector 14 with his relative Satish Bhutani in April 2021 for Rs 1.85 crore. Both became equal co-owners and paid Rs 12.95 lakh as stamp duty on the transaction.In February 2024, Satish agreed to transfer his 50% undivided share to Gulshan through a registered sale deed, making the latter the sole owner. However, Gulshan alleged that the DRO demanded Rs 14.80 lakh as stamp duty on the transaction, although, according to him, the applicable rate of 7% on the transaction value of Rs 1.06 crore worked out to Rs 7.42 lakh.He contended that he was effectively being charged again on the half share he already owned and on which stamp duty had been paid during the original purchase. He alleged that the authorities collected Rs 7.38 lakh more than the applicable amount and did not refund it despite repeated representations.Represented by advocate Aarti S Jain, Bhutani approached the consumer commission after failing to secure a refund. The DRO and DC, named as opposite parties in the complaint, did not appear before the commission despite being served. They were proceeded against ex-parte on March 20, 2026, and did not file any defence or evidence.The commission examined the complainant’s documentary evidence, including the sale deeds, and observed that there was nothing on record to disbelieve his version. It noted that the evidence had gone unrebutted in the absence of any defence from the authorities.Holding the officials guilty of deficiency in service, the commission allowed the complaint and directed them to refund Rs 7.38 lakh with 9% annual interest from February 12, 2024, until realisation.The November 3 order gives the authorities 45 days from its uploading, after the stipulated 24-hour period, to make the payment. Beyond this period, the amount will attract 12% annual interest. The commission said the complainant could initiate execution proceedings under Section 71(1) of the Consumer Protection Act, while non-compliance could also expose the officials to prosecution under Section 72, which provides for imprisonment of up to three years, a fine, or both.



Source link

Exit mobile version