Former Major League Baseball pitcher Scott Erickson is asking a California judge to order a new trial on damages in a wrongful-death lawsuit stemming from a 2020 crash that killed two young brothers, arguing that the jury’s $176 million award was excessive.Erickson, who was found negligent alongside socialite Rebecca Grossman in the deaths of Mark Iskander, 11, and Jacob Iskander, 8, is not challenging the jury’s finding that he shared responsibility for the incident. Instead, his legal team wants the court to reconsider the financial penalties imposed on him, according to the Ventura County Star.The jury awarded the boys’ family $176 million in compensatory damages for wrongful death and emotional distress. It later ordered Erickson to pay an additional $1.17 million in punitive damages, while Grossman was ordered to pay $21 million in punitive damages, AP reported.According to the Ventura County Star, Erickson’s lawyers filed a motion in October seeking a new damages trial. They argued that the compensatory award was unprecedented and would leave their client financially ruined.
Why Scott Erickson wants the damages verdict reconsidered
In the motion, Erickson’s legal team acknowledged the jury’s decision to hold him partly responsible for the boys’ deaths but argued that the amount awarded was disproportionate.His lawyers described the case as one in which emotions could run high and accused the Iskander family’s attorney of appealing to the jury’s emotions during closing arguments. They argued that the court should intervene because the verdict was influenced by passion and prejudice.The former pitcher has also asked the judge to remove the punitive damages imposed against him. His lawyers maintain that the compensatory award alone would leave him unable to meet the additional financial penalty.The Iskander family’s legal team has opposed the request. According to the Ventura County Star, attorney Andrew Owen argued that a substantial award does not, by itself, establish that jurors were influenced by prejudice or emotion.In a court filing, Owen said the verdict reflected the evidence presented during the trial, including the family’s losses and the emotional trauma suffered by the boys’ mother and younger brother, who were also at the scene.He described the jury’s decision as measured, noting that it had considered the figures presented by both sides before reaching its verdict.
What happened in the 2020 crash that killed the Iskander brothers?
The collision took place on September 29, 2020, in Westlake Village, California. Mark and Jacob were crossing Triunfo Canyon Road with their mother, Nancy Iskander, and their younger brother when they were struck by a vehicle driven by Grossman.Erickson was driving a separate vehicle ahead of Grossman. The two had reportedly met earlier and were travelling towards Grossman’s home to watch the presidential debate.During the civil trial, the Iskander family’s lawyer alleged that both drivers had been drinking margaritas and were speeding towards the intersection. He said Grossman was travelling at 73 mph in a zone with a posted speed limit of 45 mph.Witnesses said Erickson’s black SUV passed through the crosswalk without hitting the children. Nancy Iskander testified that she grabbed her youngest son and moved out of the path of Erickson’s vehicle. Grossman’s white SUV then struck Mark and Jacob.Erickson’s lawyer, Jeff Braun, stressed during the proceedings that his client’s vehicle did not make contact with the children. Grossman’s defence attorney, meanwhile, denied that she was intoxicated and argued that she had been distracted after seeing the boys’ mother move out of the way of Erickson’s vehicle.Grossman was separately convicted in 2024 of second-degree murder, gross vehicular manslaughter and hit-and-run driving. She received a sentence of 15 years to life in prison, according to AP.The civil case brought by the Iskander family against both defendants went to trial earlier this year in Van Nuys. The jury found Grossman and Erickson negligent and awarded the family compensatory damages, followed by the additional punitive awards.A hearing on Erickson’s request for a new damages trial is scheduled for later this month.