The Pratidhwani

A New York couple with three children say a downstairs neighbour screamed threats and repeatedly called police; a judge issued a temporary order as their landlord sought at least $550,000 in a lawsuit


A New York couple with three children say a downstairs neighbour screamed threats and repeatedly called police; a judge issued a temporary order as their landlord sought at least $550,000 in a lawsuit
A New York couple with three children allege repeated threats and harassment by their downstairs neighbour. (AI image)

A dispute between neighbours in a Manhattan apartment building has led to a lawsuit seeking at least $550,000 in damages and legal fees. According to a New York Post report, the building’s owner has accused a 72-year-old tenant of repeatedly disturbing families living in the apartment above hers. The allegations include verbal abuse, threats, prolonged banging on the ceiling and repeated police complaints.The latest family to report problems is that of Tara and Riad Abrahams, who moved into the four-bedroom apartment with their three children in November 2025. They have alleged that their neighbour, Anne Stockton, made their children feel unsafe at home. Their complaints also describe incidents in which police were called over alleged noise during ordinary family activities.The building owner, which operates the property at 85 East End Avenue on Manhattan’s Upper East Side, claims that the complaints are part of a pattern extending over several years. According to its lawsuit, three families who previously occupied the same apartment also experienced similar problems and eventually moved out.The case has now resulted in a temporary restraining order. A Manhattan judge signed the order days after the landlord filed its complaint. It prohibits Stockton from making unreasonable noise or engaging in conduct described as assaulting, menacing, intimidating or threatening towards the tenants and children living upstairs.The lawsuit also raises a separate financial dispute. The landlord claims Stockton has accumulated nearly $88,000 in unpaid rent. She disputes the amount, according to the ongoing litigation.

Neighbour dispute allegedly affected children

The Abrahams family said the problems began after they took possession of their apartment. According to the court documents, Stockton repeatedly shouted at them and used abusive language.The family also accused her of striking the ceiling with an object that sounded like a lead pipe. They claimed the banging sometimes continued for hours.Another concern was the number of police calls. The landlord’s complaint alleges that Stockton contacted the police at least 10 times, making accusations that the building owner described as unsupported.The family said the incidents were not limited to particular times of the day. Their complaints included occasions when their teenage daughter was alone at home, eating lunch or completing schoolwork.For the parents, the effect on their children became a major concern. Tara Abrahams told the court that the neighbour’s outbursts could be heard by the children and alleged that this was intentional.Her husband described how their 10-year-old son had begun questioning the family about the situation. “My 10-year-old son now constantly asks me, ‘What did we do wrong? Why does the lady on the 10th floor hate us?’” Riad Abrahams wrote in a sworn affidavit. “I do not know how to answer him,” he added.He said the children had become frightened inside their own home and were reluctant to remain in the apartment without their parents.

Police called during daughter’s birthday celebration

One incident mentioned in the family’s complaints involved their eldest daughter’s 16th birthday. The family had gathered for dinner and was opening presents when Stockton allegedly contacted the police. Tara Abrahams described the incident in an email to the landlord, which was included in the court filing.Riad also wrote about the episode, alleging that the neighbour shouted at the family and repeatedly referred to them as “animals”.The landlord’s complaint says several of Stockton’s noise allegations were investigated by building staff without the reported disturbance being established.A worker cited in the court papers described what happened when the building manager questioned Stockton about the source of the noise. She reportedly claimed that the sound was coming from her own kitchen cabinet.The family approached the landlord with complaints about the repeated confrontations and their impact on the children. The dispute eventually became part of the legal action against Stockton.

Earlier tenants described similar experiences

The landlord’s case also relies on complaints from people who occupied the apartment before the Abrahams family. It alleges that the problems began at least in 2013.Jennifer Gaydos Stephan was among the earlier residents. She lived in the apartment with her then-husband, Scott Hartman, and their four children.Speaking to The New York Post, Stephan said Stockton frequently struck the ceiling with a broom and left unpleasant messages outside their apartment. The notes allegedly asked the parents to control their children’s noise. “She was a disaster,” Stephan said.Stephan said she enjoyed living in the building but eventually decided to leave. Her family moved out after about two years because they could no longer tolerate the situation.A 2014 email from her then-husband to the landlord also appears in the lawsuit. He alleged that Stockton had threatened to discipline their children herself. The message described another incident in which she allegedly confronted two of the children inside an elevator. The family said they were unwilling to continue living in conditions they considered unsafe.Mitch Jacaruso, who occupied the apartment from 2014, also reported problems. In a 2017 email to the landlord, he alleged that Stockton had shouted at his children, then aged 11 and eight, inside the building’s elevator.According to his complaint, she called them “animals and horrible children” and threatened legal action against them. The landlord’s lawsuit says the incident eventually led Jacaruso to leave the building.The following tenant, Mark Weiss, reported similar concerns despite his children visiting the apartment only occasionally.In one message to the landlord, Weiss said his daughter was frightened and did not want to leave the apartment. In another email from 2019, he complained that the repeated banging on the ceiling was upsetting his children.He also reported that Stockton had come to his apartment again and said the situation was becoming a serious concern. Weiss remained in the apartment until 2024. The Abrahams family moved in approximately a year after his departure.

Landlord also claims rent arrears of nearly $88,000

The building owner’s complaint includes allegations about Stockton’s rent payments. A ledger cited in the court papers reportedly shows that she began paying rent irregularly in 2018.The landlord claims there were no major payments after 2022, apart from $24,000 received through the state’s Emergency Rental Assistance Program last spring. Even after that assistance, the alleged outstanding amount stands at nearly $88,000. Stockton disputes the arrears, and the matter remains part of the ongoing litigation.She has lived in the building since 1992 and occupies a rent-stabilised apartment on the 10th floor. Her monthly rent is $1,775, according to the lawsuit.The landlord is seeking at least $550,000 in damages and legal expenses. The temporary court order separately restricts Stockton’s conduct towards the family living above her.



Source link

Exit mobile version