The Pratidhwani

A man’s Hero Splendor was stolen in Delhi, but the insurer refused to settle his claim; consumer court found the documents sufficient and directed it to pay Rs 71,247


A man’s Hero Splendor was stolen in Delhi, but the insurer refused to settle his claim; consumer court found the documents sufficient and directed it to pay Rs 71,247
AI generated image used for representative purpose

NEW DELHI: A consumer commission in Haryana has ruled against an insurance company for withholding a claim for a stolen motorcycle despite the police failing to trace the vehicle and the court accepting their untraced report. The District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, Bhiwani, directed the insurer to pay Rs 61,247 along with Rs 10,000 as compensation and litigation cost.

Splendor’s insurance dispute

As per the commission order, Sandeep Singh, the complainant, had purchased a Splendor Plus motorcycle for Rs 64,470. The vehicle was financed through L&T Finance and insured with Bharti AXA General Insurance Company, now ICICI Lombard General Insurance Company, for an insured declared value (IDV) of Rs 61,247.The motorcycle was stolen from the Punjabi Bagh area of Delhi on July 2, 2021. Singh lodged an FIR at West Punjabi Bagh police station. The police could not trace the vehicle, and the court accepted their untraced report.The complainant lodged an insurance claim but said the company did not release the amount. He approached the commission alleging deficiency in service, seeking the vehicle’s cost with 36 percent interest, Rs 1.5 lakh in compensation and Rs 21,000 in litigation costs.The insurer submitted that the motorcycle had an own-damage policy from October 18, 2020, to October 17, 2021, and third-party coverage until October 17, 2025. It said it was informed of the theft on July 5, 2021, and sent a letter on August 6, 2021, seeking documents, followed by reminders. It argued that Singh had not submitted them and had approached the commission prematurely.L&T Finance said it had sanctioned a loan of Rs 68,510, repayable in 30 instalments of Rs 2,898 each, and that Rs 93,057.70 was outstanding as of August 31, 2024.

Commission’s findings

The bench of presiding member Saroj Bala Bohra and member Shashi Kiran Panwar found that the motorcycle was insured on the day of the theft and that the police could not recover it.The insurer had withheld the claim for want of several documents, including loan statements, foreclosure and non-repossession letters, subrogation documents and the court-approved final report, and had sought an explanation for the three-day delay in reporting the theft. However, Singh had submitted the police final report, case diary and the court’s acceptance of the untraced report.“After hearing learned counsels for the parties and going through the record, we are of the considered view that on the day of theft, the vehicle was under insurance cover and despite best efforts by police, it has not been traced out and the Court concerned accepted such report of the police. Therefore, the complainant is entitled to get IDV of the vehicle. As such, we are of the view that the documents placed on record by complainant are sufficient to release the claim of stolen vehicle,” the commission noted.Holding that the insurer could not withhold the claim when the vehicle was insured and its theft established, the commission directed payment of the IDV.“Since, the vehicle was under HPA [hire purchase agreement], therefore, the OP-financier has first right to recover the financed amount, if due any, from the awarded amount,” the bench further noted.The insurer must clear any outstanding loan directly with the financier, without penal interest or charges, and pay the remaining amount, if any, to Singh. L&T claimed dues above the IDV, but the order does not say if that figure was accepted.

Final order

Announced on October 27, 2026, the commission allowed the complaint and directed the insurers, jointly and severally, to:

  • Pay Rs 61,247, with 9 percent simple annual interest from May 28, 2024, the date of filing, until realisation.
  • Pay Rs 5,000 as compensation for harassment.
  • Pay Rs 5,000 towards litigation expenses.
  • Payment is due within 45 days, subject to cancellation of the registration certificate and other formalities.

In case of default, the awarded amount will attract 12 percent simple annual interest for the period of default. Non-compliance can invite execution under Section 71 and prosecution under Section 72 of the Consumer Protection Act, 2019, carrying up to three years’ imprisonment, a fine of up to Rs 1 lakh, or both.



Source link

Exit mobile version