Derek Jeter’s former Tampa mansion’s story includes two big names in American sports, a record-breaking real estate deal and a proposed redevelopment that could change the Davis Islands waterfront. The custom-built estate was dubbed “St. Jetersburg” and was famous for its size, privacy and wide array of luxury features.Another high-profile connection to the property was Tom Brady, who rented the mansion after joining the Tampa Bay Buccaneers in 2020. Jeter later listed the home for $29 million before closing a $22.5 million sale in 2021.
Former MLB star Derek Jeter’s Tampa mansion remains a sports landmark
Derek Jeter’s Davis Islands home was built specifically for him after he bought several adjoining lots. The 22,000-square-foot home sits on 1.25 acres with about 345 feet of open bay frontage and its waterfront setting is one of its defining features.The mansion featured seven bedrooms, multiple bathrooms, a wine cellar, movie theater, professional gym and an air-conditioned six-car garage. Outdoor features included an 80-foot saltwater pool, large covered porches and balconies and a dock with two boat lifts.Jeter also stressed privacy for the estate. A six-foot wall surrounded the home and was nicknamed locally as the “Great Wall of Jeter,” adding another distinctive element to a home already identified with the former New York Yankees star.
Tom Brady rented Derek Jeter’s waterfront estate
Brady moved into the mansion in 2020 after leaving the New England Patriots and joining the Tampa Bay Buccaneers. Another connection to one of American football’s biggest stars: Brady and Gisele Bündchen rented the property when they moved to Tampa.The timing also put the mansion at the center of a major real estate story. Brady was living there when Jeter listed the property for sale, and reports said the family obliged potential buyers’ requests to see the home. Jeter eventually put the estate on the market for $29 million and sold it for $22.5 million.The 2021 deal was reportedly the largest residential transaction in the Tampa Bay region at the time. The sale closed the book on the property’s Jeter era, while Brady’s tenure had already made the Davis Islands mansion a landmark of Tampa’s sports and celebrity real estate landscape.
| Property detail | Reported information |
| Location | Davis Islands, Tampa, Florida |
| Interior size | About 22,000 square feet |
| Land | 1.25 acres |
| Bay frontage | About 345 feet |
| Bedrooms | 7 |
| Original asking price | $29 million |
| Sale price | $22.5 million |
| Tom Brady tenancy | Began in 2020 |
Derek Jeter’s former mansion faced demolition plans
The property’s history took another turn in 2022 when a demolition permit was filed. Reports at the time indicated the structure was removable, and questions were raised about the future of a mansion associated with both Jeter and Brady.Later plans were for a much larger replacement home. The redevelopment was described as a proposed 30,000-square-foot residence with six bedrooms, nine full bathrooms, 11 half-bathrooms, a gym and a swimming pool. Construction was expected to take many years.But the demolition story has continued to evolve. Despite the demolition permit and redevelopment plans, the original Jeter mansion remained standing, according to a June 2026 Tampa Bay Times report; as such, the property remains a notable Davis Islands address, with its future now tied to the progress of the proposed replacement project.For now, the estate’s legacy is tied to its former owner Derek Jeter, its famous tenant Tom Brady and its $22.5 million sale. Its proposed transformation also illustrates how high-value waterfront real estate can change even after becoming landmarks in a city’s luxury real estate history.